Powerwise vs. RPI
See how a proposed team-ranking system compares with the rankings and tournament fields from 2022–2026. Everything is explained in plain language, including what the project assumes.
Powerwise impact: who moves up or down?
A team moving up means Powerwise gives it a better rank number than RPI does. Moving up does not guarantee an NCAA bid.
Biggest rank boosts
Biggest rank drops
Who would gain or lose an at-large bid?
An automatic bid goes to a conference champion. At-large bids are the remaining spots. The project keeps the real automatic bids, then gives the same number of at-large spots to the highest-ranked eligible teams. This is a possible result under the project’s assumptions, not an official NCAA decision.
Patterns across seasons
These are patterns in the project’s calculations. They show how the lists and hypothetical fields differ; they are not official NCAA decisions.
Teams that beat one another or did well against the same opponents may rank higher under Powerwise. A higher place alone does not guarantee an NCAA bid.
A team may rank lower under Powerwise if its direct results or score-based rating are weaker. This matters most for teams close to the last at-large spot.
Teams that often move up or down
“Net places” adds the rank difference across seasons. A positive total means the team usually ranked higher under Powerwise. It does not mean the team earned that many extra NCAA bids.
| Team | Seasons ranked higher | Net places | Added bids |
|---|
| Team | Seasons ranked lower | Net places | Lost bids |
|---|
Big differences between the two lists
These teams are at least 15 places apart in the two rankings. This is a simple way to flag large differences, not a formal statistical test.
| Season | Team | RPI place | Powerwise place | Places apart | Real tournament? | What-if field? |
|---|
Powerwise in plain English
Powerwise is a proposed way to rank college lacrosse teams. Imagine every team faced every other team. For each pair, the team with the better results earns one point. The team with more points ranks higher. It uses games already played; it does not create or predict games.
1. If they played, compare those results. 2. If not, compare results against the same opponents. 3. If still tied, use a rating based on scores and whether games were home, away, or neutral. Score margins count only up to seven goals. The winner of each comparison gets one point.
It uses games through Selection Sunday. Real conference champions keep their automatic spots; Powerwise fills the remaining open spots (at-large bids). Seeds, matchups, and hosts are project assumptions. No games are simulated.
How close are the rankings?
Each dot is a team. Hover to see its name and click to select it. A lower rank number means a higher place on the list.
Season summary
Compare every team
RPI is the NCAA’s score based on wins and schedule strength. Rank difference = RPI place minus Powerwise place. +5 means Powerwise puts the team five places higher.
| Powerwise place | Team | Powerwise points | RPI score | RPI place | Rank difference | Real tournament? |
|---|
Actual NCAA bracket
Real NCAA bracket
This is the real tournament bracket, including teams, seeds, scores, and game locations. Quarterfinals and later were played at neutral sites.
Powerwise what-if bracket
How the Powerwise what-if bracket is made
The project uses the Powerwise ranking to choose the what-if at-large teams. It also makes the assumptions below. RPI is shown for comparison, but it does not choose teams in this bracket.
Powerwise what-if bracket
This shows a possible field and bracket path. It does not predict scores or winners. Assumptions: actual conference champions stay in; Powerwise fills the open spots; the lowest-ranked automatic-bid teams play in the opening round; the top eight remaining teams are seeded; and the higher-ranked team is assumed to host campus games. These bracket and host choices are project decisions, not rules given by the proposal.
Where games are played
For opening- and first-round games, “Home” means the project assumes the higher-ranked team hosts. Actual hosting would depend on NCAA site bids. Later rounds are neutral-site. The proposal does not set exact bracket pairings.
RPI and Powerwise: two ways to rank teams
RPI looks at wins and schedule strength. Powerwise compares teams directly, using scores only when the game results do not settle the comparison.
A record-and-schedule score
RPI combines three things: how often a team wins, how often its opponents win, and how often those opponents’ opponents win. The men’s lacrosse formula gives those parts 25%, 50%, and 25% of the score.
Winning by 10 goals does not count more than winning by 1. RPI is one factor the NCAA committee considers today; it does not automatically award a tournament spot.
Imagine every team played every other team
For each pair of teams, give one point to the team with the better record against the other. If they did not play or tied, compare their records against the same opponents. If that still does not decide it, use a Power Rating based on scores and where games were played. “Common opponents” means teams both teams played.
The Power Rating counts no win or loss as more than a seven-goal margin. That limits the benefit of running up the score.
How are NCAA teams chosen today?
Conference champions receive automatic bids. A committee picks the remaining at-large teams using several factors, including RPI, schedule strength, and results against other teams. It does not simply take the top RPI teams.
The proposal would use the Powerwise list to choose at-large teams after automatic bids are awarded. The NCAA would still run the tournament. Powerwise is not the current rule; the NCAA was still reviewing it in September 2026.
How ties are decided
A tie can happen when comparing two teams or when teams finish with the same total points.
If teams finish with the same Powerwise points
Compare only the tied teams’ results against one another. For two teams, the better record goes first. For three or four teams, make a small standings table from their games against each other. If some are still tied, repeat the tie rules for that smaller group. If everyone is still tied—or more than four teams are tied—use Power Rating.
Team A is 2–0 against the other tied teams, Team B is 1–1, Team C is 0–2. Order them A, B, C. If all are 1–1, the Power Rating decides.
Teams can finish with the same point total. These rules decide who goes higher on the final list.
Number definitions
Definitions for the words and numbers used in the dashboard.
| Powerwise place | A team’s position in the Powerwise list. #1 is highest. |
| Powerwise points | How many of its one-on-one comparisons the team won. More points usually means a higher place. |
| RPI score | A score from 0 to 1 based on wins and schedule strength. Higher scores rank better. |
| RPI place | The team’s position in the RPI list. #1 is highest. |
| Rank difference | RPI place minus Powerwise place. +10 means Powerwise places the team 10 spots higher. |
| Power Rating | A team-strength score estimated from game scores and whether each game was home, away, or neutral. The margin is capped at seven goals. |
| Seed | A team’s numbered place in a bracket. #1 is the top seed. In the what-if bracket, the project assumes some teams host; the NCAA would decide actual hosts. |
| Automatic bid | A spot awarded to a conference champion. (The proposal uses “AQ,” short for automatic qualifier.) |
| At-large bid | A spot the NCAA gives to a team that did not receive an automatic conference bid. |
| Home / Away | The actual bracket shows the official host. In the what-if bracket, “Home” is an assumption: the higher-ranked team is shown hosting. Neutral-site games are played at neither team’s campus. |
| How similar are the rankings? | This number shows whether the two lists put teams in a similar order. 1.00 means almost the same order; it is not an accuracy percentage. A team can still move many places. |
| Not simulated | The what-if bracket shows who could play whom. It does not predict scores, winners, or a champion. |
Sources, assumptions, and calculation checks
Here is what went into the rankings and what the what-if brackets assume.
1. Which games count?
For each year, the project counts Division I games played up to the NCAA selection day (Selection Sunday). It includes conference tournament games, but does not use later NCAA tournament games to rank teams for that year. Scores were checked against NCAA and school records. Team lists come from archived season records; they are not a separately certified NCAA membership count.
2. How are teams ranked?
RPI: This NCAA score combines a team’s wins with how strong its opponents and their opponents were. The formula weights those three parts 25%, 50%, and 25%. This project recalculates RPI from game results.
Powerwise: Imagine every team played every other team once. For each imaginary matchup, the team with the better direct record gets a point. If the teams did not play or are tied, compare how they did against opponents they both played. If that still does not settle it, compare their Power Ratings, which use scores and game location. Score margins count only up to seven goals.
Home-field assumption: The proposal says home field should count but does not give one required number. This project estimates one shared home-field adjustment for each season. It then chooses team ratings that fit all the adjusted game scores as closely as possible. Using a different home-field estimate could change some ratings.
3. What does the Powerwise what-if bracket assume?
- Real conference champions keep their automatic bids; this project does not replay conference tournaments.
- The what-if bracket has the same number of at-large spots as the actual tournament.
- A team must have at least as many Division I wins as losses to be considered.
- The remaining spots go to the highest-ranked eligible teams without automatic bids. RPI does not choose these teams.
- The project uses the Powerwise order for seeds, places the lowest-ranked automatic-bid teams in opening games, and assumes the higher-ranked campus team hosts early games. It follows a fixed bracket layout.
- The proposal does not give exact bracket pairings, site bids, travel rules, or a full tournament placement formula. Those parts are project assumptions. No scores or winners are simulated.
4. What does the 2024 comparison show?
The project’s 2024 team order is very close to the proposal’s published order: rank similarity is 0.994 on a scale where 1.00 means the same order. This is not “99.4% accuracy.” The proposal’s printed point totals add up to one more point than its 76 teams can produce if each pair gets one point. No correction is listed, so the project keeps the printed numbers and compares the order instead of guessing which number to change.
As another check, the project’s share of matchups decided by direct results is close to the proposal’s example. The shared-opponent percentages differ slightly; the paper does not specify every detail needed to know exactly why.
5. What does the RPI check mean?
The project compared its recalculated RPI scores with a third-party archive of end-of-season scores. Those are not official NCAA scores from Selection Sunday, and the comparison uses full-season results, including tournament games. So this check is useful for comparison, but it does not prove every reconstructed RPI value is correct. The dashboard labels project RPI values as reconstructed.
6. Is Powerwise the NCAA rule?
No. The NCAA still uses its committee and current selection rules. As of the September 2026 report, the NCAA was still reviewing the Powerwise idea. The Powerwise bracket here is a historical what-if, not an official NCAA bracket.
Technical check numbers
For 2024, the published and reconstructed Powerwise orders have a Spearman correlation of 0.994 across 76 teams. In 2023 and 2024, the project’s head-to-head matchup shares round to the proposal’s values (17.6% and 17.8%). Common-opponent matchup shares are 46.1% and 44.6%, compared with 45.2% and 45.1% in the proposal.
The RPI archive matches to four decimal places for 21/73 teams in 2022, 12/75 in 2023, 76/76 in 2024, 2/77 in 2025, and 4/77 in 2026. These are comparisons to a third-party full-season archive, not official NCAA Selection Sunday tables.
Sources
- Powerwise proposal — explains the proposed pair-by-pair system, seven-goal score cap, and tie rules.
- NCAA RPI explanation — official RPI formula.
- NCAA championship manual — eligibility and current selection rules.
- NCAA September 2026 report — status of the Powerwise review.
- NCAA past brackets — actual fields, seeds, results, and locations.
- Game-by-game NCAA and school sources are listed in the project data files. The RPI comparison uses LaxMath’s archive, not an official NCAA archive.
Army Lacrosse: what might have changed?
See how Army ranks in both systems and whether it makes the project’s possible tournament field. Choose a season above to highlight that year.
Army, season by season
Rank #1 is highest. A bid is not guaranteed by rank: each year has a limited number of at-large places. The what-if uses the real conference champions and requires an eligible team to have at least as many wins as losses.
| Season | RPI place | Powerwise place | What happened | Powerwise what-if | Simple explanation |
|---|
In 2022, 2024, and 2025, Powerwise gives Army a better place than RPI does. Powerwise compares direct results, results against shared opponents, and then scores adjusted for game location. RPI uses wins and the strength of the schedule.
It does not mean Army would have played different games or won the NCAA tournament. The project keeps actual conference bids fixed and only changes who gets the at-large spots. It does not simulate game scores or winners.